Honda CR-V vs Toyota RAV4 used under $25,000 CAD. which is the better buy?
Family SUV, budget $22,000 to $25,000 CAD, want reliability and low running costs.
May 15, 2026
Photo by Nithula Perera on Pexels
Cars discussed
Toyota RAV4
Slightly stronger owner sentiment for long-term reliability and lower maintenance costs. The hybrid variant adds exceptional fuel economy on top.
Honda CR-V
Just as reliable as the RAV4 with a more spacious cargo area. The 1.5T engine on 2017-2019 models had oil dilution issues in cold climates, so check that year range carefully.
Mazda CX-5
If neither fits your budget, the CX-5 offers premium interior quality and strong reliability for less money used.
Both are excellent picks in the $22,000 to $25,000 CAD range. Owner data shows overwhelmingly positive sentiment for both the RAV4 and CR-V for long-term reliability and low maintenance costs. Neither will disappoint.
The RAV4 edges ahead for one reason: the hybrid version. RAV4 Hybrid owners consistently report fuel economy around 6 L/100km and describe the eCVT as completely trouble-free at high mileage. If you find a RAV4 Hybrid in your budget, take it.
For the standard gasoline versions, the choice comes down to cargo space. The CR-V has a larger, more practical trunk and a better folding rear seat. The RAV4 has a taller ride height and marginally more ground clearance.
One specific warning for the CR-V: the 2017, 2018, and early 2019 models with the 1.5T engine have a documented oil dilution problem in cold Canadian winters. Engine oil would thin from gasoline mixing in during short trips. Honda issued a software update but the issue was never fully resolved on those years. Stick to a 2020 or later CR-V to avoid it entirely.
Bottom line: RAV4 Hybrid if available, 2020+ CR-V otherwise, standard RAV4 as a third option. All three are safe long-term buys.
Want to dig deeper on a specific car?
Related questions