BMW
i5
Tesla
Model S
BMW i5 vs Tesla Model S: 2024 Comparison
The short answer
Based on available data, the Tesla Model S comes out ahead of the BMW i5 on power. Check the specs table and owner sentiment below for the full comparison before deciding between the two. Both are covered by real owner reports on CarWizz.
Specs side by side
What owners say
i5
Overall
Mixed to positive sentiment overall, with a clear distinction between praise for its luxury, comfort, and refinement, and criticism for its driving dynamics, software reliability, and platform origins. The vehicle is consistently described as a comfortable, quiet, and well-built luxury sedan with a premium interior feel, superior sound deadening, and a smooth ride. It is favorably compared to its sibling, the i4, for being more refined, spacious, and feeling like a more purposefully engineered electric vehicle.
Best version to buy
Insufficient owner data available to declare a consensus "best" trim. The M60 performance variant is mentioned but receives criticism for its handling.
Known issues
- ⚠Software glitches and system failures: includes complete audio system failure (no sound from any source), iDrive screen going blank/not booting, personal assistant malfunctions, and general bugginess. Frequency: recurrent.
- ⚠Digital Key/Phone-as-Key unreliability: failures to unlock or start the vehicle, potentially leaving the owner stranded, requiring a physical key as a backup. Frequency: recurrent.
- ⚠Handling and driving dynamics: described as feeling like a "boat," with noticeable understeer, lack of agility, and steering that lacks feedback and precision compared to expectations for BMW or rivals like Porsche. Frequency: recurrent.
Model S
Overall
Sentiment is mixed and varies significantly by vehicle generation. Long-term owners of older models (specifically pre-2021, with mentions of a 2015 model) report severe dissatisfaction with long-term reliability and ownership costs, describing the vehicle as poorly designed for longevity with frequent, expensive failures. In contrast, discussions of newer models (post-2021) are more focused on competitive positioning, with feedback indicating they are perceived as technologically capable but lagging in interior luxury, build quality, and overall refinement compared to newer premium electric vehicles.
Best version to buy
Insufficient owner data available to designate a specific model year or trim (e.g., Long Range vs. Plaid) as the "best" among community discussions.
Known issues
- ⚠Poor long-term reliability (older models): Multiple expensive failures per year out of warranty, including door handles, trunk latches, 12V battery systems, infotainment screens, and suspension components (control arms).
- ⚠Full Self-Driving (FSD) / Autopilot system flaws: Phantom braking, unreliable object detection due to cameras-only sensor suite, hard braking for shadows, erratic lane changes, and general inability to be trusted without constant supervisi…
- ⚠Subpar build quality and interior materials: Described as "low build quality," lacking the refinement, comfort, and quietness expected in the luxury segment.
The verdict
The Tesla Model S is the better choice for most buyers.
It has more power on its best-equipped version than the BMW i5, based on the data above. If efficiency matters more to you than outright power, the BMW i5 is worth a closer look instead.
Explore further
Not sure which one fits you?
Answer a few questions and get a personalized recommendation.
Frequently asked questions
Which is more reliable, the BMW i5 or the Tesla Model S?
Owner reports show similar reliability sentiment for the BMW i5 and the Tesla Model S. Check the known issues listed above for specific differences between the two.
Which is better for families, the BMW i5 or the Tesla Model S?
Both seat a similar number of passengers based on our data. The BMW i5 is classed as a Station wagon, the Tesla Model S as a Liftback, which affects cargo space and ride height for family use.
Which has better fuel economy, the BMW i5 or the Tesla Model S?
Fuel consumption data is limited for one or both models. Check the specs table above for the figures available on each catalogued version.
Which is cheaper to maintain, the BMW i5 or the Tesla Model S?
Exact maintenance costs aren't in our data, but owner reports mention cost-related concerns more often for the Tesla Model S than the BMW i5. See the known issues comparison above.