Best used 3-row SUV under $25k?

For a used three-row SUV under $25,000 that prioritizes reliability for daily driving and road trips, the Mazda CX-9 is your best bet. It offers the lowest median price in this group, and owner data shows no frequent major mechanical issues. The Honda Pilot is a close second, with a strong reputation and no standout problems reported. The Toyota Highlander, despite its popularity, has a significant reliability risk in your price range.

The Toyota Highlander has a median used price of $24,539, which fits your budget, but owner data reveals a very frequent issue with 8-speed automatic transmission failures on gas models from 2017-2022. Repairs can cost around $7,000 or more. This makes it a risky choice for a family needing dependable transportation without expensive repairs. You’d likely end up with a model year in that affected range.

The Honda Pilot has a median price of $22,951, well under your cap. Owner reports do not highlight any frequent or costly problems, making it a dependable option for family use. It suits buyers who want a spacious, proven SUV without worrying about model-year-specific failures. You can find a good example within your budget.

The Mazda CX-9 has a median price of $21,489, the lowest here, leaving room for a newer or lower-mileage example. Owner data shows no major recurring issues, so it’s a reliable choice for daily driving and road trips. It’s ideal for budget-conscious families who want a solid, affordable three-row SUV.

For your situation, go with the Mazda CX-9 for the best value and reliability. If you prefer a larger interior, the Honda Pilot is a safe alternative. Skip the Toyota Highlander unless you can verify the transmission is not from the 2017-2022 gas models.