Cars discussed
Audi A4
If you prioritize premium driving feel and are committed to meticulous, scheduled maintenance, the 2017-2018 model is the reliable choice within the Audi lineup.
Toyota Camry
It offers the lowest long-term cost and worry-free ownership, making it the financially smart alternative to the Audi.
Mazda 6
It provides a more engaging driving experience than the Camry and strong reliability, balancing your desire for feel with lower costs.
You are looking at the right A4 generation. The 2017-2018 Audi A4 (B9 generation) is notably more reliable than the problematic earlier models, with owners praising its premium feel and driving dynamics. However, it still requires strict, scheduled maintenance using premium parts and fluids to avoid costly repairs. Long-term ownership costs will be significantly higher than a Toyota or Mazda.
The newer Toyota Camry or Mazda 6 will provide far lower cost of ownership and excellent reliability. The Camry is the benchmark for trouble-free longevity, while the Mazda 6 offers a more engaging drive that might satisfy your desire for a better feel without the Audi's maintenance risk. Both will be cheaper to own over time.
Want to dig deeper on a specific car?